Homemade Goodness, Made With Love

Everything on our menu is made right here in our kitchen — from scratch, with care. It’s the way we’ve always done things, and the way we’ll always keep doing them.

Some of our guests’ favorite dishes include:

• Our fluffy Challah French Toast
• The classic, stacked‑just‑right Reuben
• The Schmoozer, a true comfort sandwich
• Gabbie’s Tuna Melt, named after our daughter
• Our creamy, comforting Tomato Bisque
• And of course, our desserts… if you can save room

We believe great food should be generous, affordable, and made with intention — and that every plate should feel like it came from your own family’s kitchen.

A Nostalgic Diner With Heart

When you walk into Scotty’s, you’ll feel that cozy, nostalgic diner vibe from the 1950s and 1960s — warm lighting, friendly faces, and a space filled with stories. It’s a place where conversations linger, coffee is refilled without asking, and breakfast is served all day, just the way it should be.

Proudly Family‑Run Since the Beginning

Scotty’s Café began when Scott moved from Miami, Florida, to Ohio to marry Gina — and brought his passion for cooking and hospitality with him. Today, we still run the café as a family, with Scott, Gina, and our daughters working side by side.

Our philosophy has never changed:
“Make everything homemade, keep it fresh, and treat every person who walks in like family.”

We’re incredibly grateful for the community that has supported us all these years — for the regulars who’ve been with us since the beginning and for new guests discovering us for the first time.

A Central Ohio Favorite Worth Visiting

From hearty roast beef sandwiches and all‑day breakfasts to homemade soups and scratch‑made sweets, we’ve been serving Bexley and the greater Columbus area with pride for decades. If you haven’t been in yet, we truly hope you’ll stop by soon.

We’ll have a warm meal waiting — and we can’t wait to welcome you.